Overview
Chaffee County home prices just hit their highest September in five years. And homes are taking more than twice as long to sell. Both are true.
So is this a seller's market or a buyer's market? Stick with me as I break down inventory, buyer demand, and prices across Chaffee County this September, what's really behind that five-year high, and what it all means for you as we head into fall.
📈
Inventory
9 Months of Supply
🍂
Buyer Demand
Slowing Into Fall
💲
Home Prices
A 5-Year High, With a Catch
01 - InventoryFewer New Listings, But Supply Is Taking Longer to Clear
Last month I told you sellers had come off the sidelines. In September, they went back. New listings dropped to 51, down 39% from August, though that's about the same as last September. This looks like the normal fall slowdown we see in Chaffee County this time of year, not a sudden change.
Active listings dipped to 322, down from 348 in August. But here's the number to watch: weeks of inventory went up, to 39 weeks. That's about nine months of supply. Fewer homes are coming on, but fewer homes are selling too, so the supply we already have is taking longer to clear. Anything over six months is generally considered buyer's market territory, and we're well past that.
322
Active listings county-wide
(down from 348 in August)
51
New listings in September
(−39% MoM, +2% YoY)
39
Weeks of inventory
(about 9 months)
02- Buyer DemandThis Is Where the Slowdown Shows Up
36 homes closed in September, down 22% from August and down 28% from last September. Pending sales fell too, to 43, down from 54 last month. Since pending sales are the homes going under contract now, they tell us what will close over the next month or two, so I'd expect October to stay on the quieter side.
Then there's time on market. Median days in MLS climbed to 74 days, 20 days more than August and more than double last September's 33 days. A year ago, a typical home went under contract in about a month. Now it's closer to two and a half.
"A year ago, a typical home went under contract in about a month. Now it's closer to two and a half."
74
Median days on market
(+41 days YoY)
43
New pending listings
(down from 54 in August)
36
Closed sales
(−28% YoY, −22% MoM)
03 - Home PricesA Five-Year High, But Here's the Catch
With fewer sales and homes sitting longer, you'd expect prices to drop. They didn't. The median closed price in September was $772,500. That's up 8% from August, up 10% from last September, and the highest September median in the last five years.
So how does that fit with everything else? A median price tells you about the homes that sold, not about every home on the market. And in September, the homes that sold skewed higher-end. The median for single-family homes was about $852,000, up from $782,000 last September, so buyers at the upper end of the market drove most of this month's closings.
Condos and townhomes went the other way. Their median dropped to about $514,000, down from $647,000 last year, and they took a median of 105 days to sell. That's only 8 sales, so don't read too much into it. But if you're shopping in that price range, it's good news: those properties are selling for a bit less and sitting longer.
Here's the bottom line on price. With only 36 closings, a handful of high-end sales can push the median up quickly. A higher median doesn't mean your house got 10% more valuable this month. It means the homes that sold this month happened to be pricier ones.
Single Family
$852,000
Up from $782K last Sept.
Condo/Townhouse
$514,000
Down from $647K last Sept.
County Median
$772,500
+10% vs. last year
04 - List Price ReceivedBuyers Have About $10,000 More Room Than Last Year
This is the number that tells you how much negotiating is happening: percent of list price received. In September, sellers in Chaffee County got 95.9% of their asking price, down from 97.2% last September. Year to date, it's 96.7%, down 0.8% from last year.
Let's make that real. On an $800,000 list price, 95.9% means buyers are getting about $33,000 off on average. A year ago, it was about $22,000. That's roughly $10,000 more negotiating room than this time last year, especially on homes that have been sitting.
95.9%
Percent of list price
received in September
96.7%
Year-to-date average
(−0.8% vs. last year)
05 - What that means for youSo, Is It a Buyer's Market? Definitely.
Back to the question from the start: prices at a five-year high, and homes sitting twice as long. The headline price makes this look like a seller's market. But look at how the market actually behaves. There's nine months of supply, homes are taking 74 days to sell, and sellers are giving up more off their asking price than a year ago. All of that points the same way. This is a buyer's market, and September leaned further that way than any month we've covered this year. Prices haven't come down because the homes that do sell skew upper-end. The real shift is in pace and negotiating power.
If you're a buyer, don't let the median price scare you off. It reflects which homes sold, not what you'll have to pay. You have time on your side, so do your homework, make an offer below list, and ask for concessions
Sellers who've been on the market all summer may be more willing to negotiate than you think. Many take their homes off the market for winter and relist in spring, so the ones still listed now tend to be motivated
If you're selling, the headline price won't sell your home. Expect it to take longer and price for today's market. Homes that are priced right and show well are still selling, sometimes fast. The ones priced too high are the ones still sitting at 74 days and counting
"Prices haven't come down, but the real shift is in pace and negotiating power. If you've been waiting for the right moment to negotiate, this is it."
06 - Full BreakdownWatch the September 2026 Market Update Video
I cover all the numbers in detail, including why prices hit a five-year high while homes sit longer, how single-family homes and condos are moving in opposite directions, and how much more room buyers have to negotiate. I also share what a listing agent told me this week about wiggle room on price, and a well-priced home I saw go under contract right away.